Was Colby Armstrong wrong in not telling anyone he was feeling light headed after he collided with Vancouver's Ryan Kesler in a game Saturday?
It's a question that is being asked now that Armstrong has been sidelined indefinitely with a concussion.
On the collision with Kesler, Armstrong suffered a cracked toe. But he also felt dizzy and lightheaded.
Remember, he missed 2 months with an ankle injury, and was playing in his 4th game since his return when he suffered the toe/concussion.
Armstrong has suffered pretty much every injury you can think off while he's been a Leaf: hand, knee, groin and eye injuries have meant Armstrong has played in 50 % of the games while he's been in Toronto.
That frustration - and the culture of hockey - played a large role in Armstrong deciding to try and hide his symptoms for a couple of days.
"If a guy doesn't tell you he has any symptoms, it's no different than 90 % of men who never go in for a checkup," said coach Ron Wilson. "We have all of these issues and that's just the way a lot of us were brought up: Unless you think you're dying you don't say anything, you don't see the doctor, you don't tell anybody."
It is a mindset that Wilson admits should change, but in a sport where competition is fierce and there are always people looking to take your job away, it's understandable in the eyes of the coach.
"Colby I think was trying to be noble," said Wilson. "He’s had a lot of injuries and he doesn't want to be known as fragile or injury prone so he didn't alert anybody until he felt really bad."
Armstrong skipped practise on Sunday because of his toe injury. He took part in the morning skate ahead of Monday's game vs. the Kings. It was early in the afternoon when he felt quite ill and was then diagnosed with a concussion.
"I talked to him after that game on the phone for quite a while and he never had a concussion before and he thought it was one of those things that he could shake off the next day," said defenseman Luke Schenn. "He probably thought a good night’s rest and hopefully it would go away."
It didn't and now the Leafs have lost Armstrong once again, and his hockey future may be in doubt. He has one more year on his $3 million a year contract.
"From talking with him that's what it sounded like, he didn't really know he had a concussion," said defenseman John-Michael Liles. "I don't think he was hiding anything from anybody. It’s not exactly something that jumps out a lot of times."
Whether he was hiding anything or not can be debated and discussed. But there is no doubt Armstrong knew he wasn't right and didn't respond to the situation immediately.
“If you don’t feel right, then you’re probably not right,” Keith Primeau told the National Post. Primeau's career was cut short by repeated concussions. “And that’s one of the most powerful messages in the education process: It’s imperative that you listen to your body.”
"From his point of view it's a normal reaction," Wilson said of Armstrong's decision to not say anything right away. "That's old school right there where you don't tell anybody and you hope you can fight through it. At least he realized even if it was late in the day he couldn't fake his way through the feelings he had."